draft project

One Raga, Many Traditions

the same notes, every tradition

Take one raga or scale at a time and follow it across traditions โ€” Carnatic, Hindustani, Western, Arabic and beyond โ€” on voice, piano, guitar, and GeoShred, until the differences and the common ground are truly heard.

A copy carries over only the public parts you see here โ€” the owners' private files never leave their own vaults.

๐Ÿšง Draft โ€” not final. This page was auto-generated as day-one scaffolding for the project and still needs a human pass before it reads as finished. The blanks and placeholders below are intentional โ€” someone who runs this project should fill them in and delete this notice.

Mohanam โ€” across traditions

Raga one. A major pentatonic โ€” five notes, no half-steps, no note that clashes with another โ€” which is exactly why it shows up, under different names, in nearly every musical tradition on earth. The friendliest possible place to start listening across borders.

The scale

  • Carnatic โ€” Mohanam. Arohana: S Rโ‚‚ Gโ‚ƒ P Dโ‚‚ แน  ยท Avarohana: แน  Dโ‚‚ P Gโ‚ƒ Rโ‚‚ S. No madhyama (M), no nishada (N) โ€” that's what makes it pentatonic.
  • Western โ€” major pentatonic. In C: C D E G A. The black keys of the piano are one too (starting on Fโ™ฏ) โ€” which is why "only the black keys" always sounds vaguely raga-like.
  • Hindustani โ€” Bhoop (Bhoopali). Same five notes, a serious evening raga; the phrasing and the resting notes differ from Mohanam even though the scale is identical.
  • Arabic / maqam โ€” no exact pentatonic match (the maqam system leans on quarter-tones and different intervals), so this is the tradition to listen to for contrast โ€” where the crossover stops.

What differs (the actual point)

The notes are the shared skeleton; the treatment is where traditions part ways โ€” which note you rest on, the ornaments (gamaka in Carnatic, meend in Hindustani, none in a plain Western reading), the tempo, the emotional home. Same five notes, four different feelings.

Renditions (record and link โ€” one minute each)

  • Voice
  • Piano
  • Guitar
  • GeoShred (for the gamaka the piano can't bend into)

Keep them side by side here so the comparison is one click, not one memory.